The citizens of Lake Eden are preparing for the Winter Carnival. Hannah Swensen, owner and baker of The Cookie Jar, is busy preparing her cookies for the festivities. Connie Mac, a famous baker, is in charge of creating the Winter Carnival cake. When her delivery van with the cake gets put in a ditch, Connie Mac takes over Hannah’s bakery to recreate her cake.
When Connie Mac turns up dead in Hannah’s kitchen, Hannah gets on the case. Since her kitchen is now a crime scene, Hannah moves to Lake Eden’s Inn to create her cookies that she is asked to do in replacement of Connie Mac’s cake. While at the Inn, Hannah has access to question Connie Mac’s people. The only person missing is Janie, Connie Mac’s assistant. Hannah wants to solve this mystery so she can have her kitchen back and to clear Janie’s name.
This was read by Suzanne Toren.